I See Dumb People!

by Ryan M. Healy

in Business, Copywriting, Sales, Twitter

I hate to put it so bluntly, but people are dumber than you think.

No, I’m not some misanthrope (I really do like people)… and yes, there will be a marketing lesson here. So please bear with me for a moment as I present a few seemingly unrelated pieces of information.

In the past few weeks, there’s been a firestorm of controversy about Google Sidewiki.

Those who are against Sidewiki argue that most Internet users will mistakenly assume that the comments on Sidewiki are actually on the “host” web site itself. This naturally opens the door for much misunderstanding and miscommunication.

On the flip side, people who are in favor of Sidewiki say that you’d have to be an idiot not to know the difference between the web site and the Sidewiki… that the difference between the two is patently obvious.

Unfortunately, I think the latter group is overestimating people’s intelligence. I would like to believe that the majority of people are highly educated and blessed with uncommon discernment, but something tells me otherwise.

Which brings me to Twitter

What You Can Learn from Twitter’s Trending Topics

Twitter measures the popularity of memes and publishes the most popular ones in a column labeled “Trending Topics.” This column is constantly changing as memes come and go.

For instance, just a few days ago, “No God” became a trending topic when (it appears) a well-meaning person tried to get this phrase to become popular: “No God, No Peace. Know God, Know Peace.”

The good intentions backfired… Twitter only picked up “No God” as a trending topic… and the trend fed on itself for the better part of a day.

Anyway, have you ever clicked these trending topics and perused the tweets of strangers? I have often done so out of sheer curiosity, the “No God” meme being a perfect example.

What I’m consistently shocked by is the number of illiterate people using Twitter. When I click on a trending topic, half the time I can’t even understand what people are saying. It’s practically gibberish — even though the majority of these people are native English speakers!

Next time you’re on Twitter, click on one or more of the trending topics and you’ll see what I mean.

But maybe Twitter is not the best place to look for intelligence and is poor evidence that people are lacking in the IQ department. So let me give you another example…

“My Hard Drive Won’t Accept My Credit Card.”

Last week, at my weekly Wednesday morning breakfast, I was reading the back page of Tidbits because there were some humorous anecdotes. One stood out to me as being illustrative of the ignorance that pervades modern society.

A lady was seen at work putting a credit card into her floppy drive and pulling it out very quickly. When I inquired as to what she was doing, she said she was shopping on the Internet and they kept asking for her credit card number, so she was using the ATM “thingy.”

And in spite of stories like this, are we to believe your average Internet surfer is going to understand Sidewiki and how frames work? Puh-leeze.

Most people think you’re speaking a foreign language when you give a basic instruction like, “Type this URL into your browser bar.”

If a person doesn’t know what a URL is, there is little chance he will even remotely understand Sidewiki, much less how it works.

Lesson: Keep It Simple Stoopid!

Which brings me to the marketing lesson of this post. That is, as much as possible, keep your sales message and ordering process simple.

The simpler they are, the more sales you’ll get.

Use plain language (plainer than what I’ve used in this post). Use a simple checkout process and, if possible, reduce the number of clicks between your sales message and the final checkout page. Never assume that your prospects “should be able to figure it out.”

You must always simplify because most folks on the Internet are not as smart as you are. They don’t understand things like HTML, URLs, frames, cookies, Javascript, plug-ins, etc. Some of them don’t even understand the basics of shopping online.

Are there times when you might want to “upgrade” your language? Certainly. But for most products sold on the Internet, the advice to use plain language holds true. (And a simple ordering process is good no matter who your target market is.)

The fact is, the Internet is crawling with people of average and less-than-average intelligence. This is not something you should be upset about. Rather, I suggest you make peace with stupidity — and even cater to it.

After all, as a marketer, it’s not your job to change the way people are… your job is to meet people where they’re at. And so you work with what you’ve got.

What do you think? Do you agree with my premise, or am I going too far here? Leave a comment below and let me know.

-Ryan M. Healy

Popularity: 6% [?]

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Twitter
  • Technorati
  • Live
  • LinkedIn
  • MySpace
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
  • "No marketer ever went broke overestimating the ignorance of the average buyer." -Dan Kennedy

    BTW, the bumper sticker that reads, "I See Stupid People" is my husband's favorite. He had to explain it to me over his own laughter.
    #SixthSenseIgnorance

    Great, as always Ryan!
  • Thanks for sharing Dan's quote. I had forgotten about that. I think P.T. Barnum also said something similar.

    Thanks for commenting, Gina!

    Ryan
  • Colin
    Nobody likes a "corrector", (they're annoying people) but with that said... (apologies in advance)... the original source is...

    "No one ever went broke underestimating the taste of the American public."
    - H.L Mencken

    And the full one is:

    "No one in this world, so far as I know — and I have researched the records for years, and employed agents to help me — has ever lost money by underestimating the intelligence of the great masses of the plain people. Nor has anyone ever lost public office thereby."

    As found in the September 19,1926 issue of the Chicago Tribune in an article entitled "Notes on Journalism"

    So it's *not* just Americans... it's the plebes, the proles, the working class, the unwashed masses, etc. in general... elitist, yes. true, unfortunately also yes.
  • Cool, Colin! I love knowing the truth about the source of quotes. So many are not sourced correctly.

    I've done some research on quotes attributed to Einstein and have found the same thing -- that Einstein never said what we think he did!

    Ryan
  • Colin
    :) I think that's a good indicator of greatness... when people start attributing quotes you never said to you.
  • Hey Ryan,

    Nevermind the other people...
    Sometimes I do "stoopid" things myself.
    So I can hardly ask for more from
    others.

    So I guess, I'd have to agree. People
    in general aren't the brightest bulbs.

    This includes me.

    And most of the time we're walking
    around in a trance... like a buncha
    zombies.

    Sometimes I look back on it all and
    wonder where the day went to. Or the
    month.

    To my surprise, I usually get a lot done.
    But I don't know who does the work...

    Must be elves...

    Courtney
  • Hey Courtney - I'm as big of an idiot as anybody.

    "Pride cometh before the fall," as the saying goes. :-)

    Ryan
  • Ryan,

    You're absolutely right.
    Unfortunately, American society has been dumbed down by watching too much TV and relying on technology as a substitute for critical thought.

    As good marketers, we should be aware of and adapt to the trend instead of trying to fight it. Simple language in marketing copy - for folks of all intelligence levels - increases the chances of making a sale. And that's our ultimate goal.

    Excellent and insightful take!
  • Ah yes, TV... perhaps the subject of another post altogether.

    Thanks for the comment, Brian!

    Ryan
  • When I give talks to business groups about internet marketing, I explain the different parts of search results paid vs. organic. I then show an example of Google AdSense ads. Many do not know the difference and are surprised.

    I find it hard to believe that the typical user will understand what sidewiki is. And there are already programs out to use sidewiki for spamming.

    John
  • That's a great point, John. I've personally experienced the same thing -- where people don't know the difference between organic search results and paid search results.

    Ryan
  • Barry
    You're right on, Ryan. Here's more evidence (hundreds of cases of it) that stupidity, ignorance, and rudeness are on the increase: http://notalwaysright.com/

    The site runs anecdotes sent in by people who have to deal with the public. There are about five new stories added every day. I read it to keep myself grounded in what we're dealing with.
  • Barry - Great site! Thanks for sharing it. I read a few of the stories and they're shocking. Good material for future posts. :-)

    Ryan
  • Hey Ryan,

    Here lies one of the problems... how many people who don't understand Sidewiki will hop on the bandwagon to use one of the new spam programs?

    Then get upset after they get banned... after all they are using their new, can't miss marketing/spam tool correctly!
  • Keith - Those same people probably won't even understand that what they're doing is spam. Even today, I talk to marketers who truly don't "get" what email spam is (even though the law went into effect in 2003).

    Ryan
  • Ian
    Hi Ryan -

    Thanks for your comment on the EZA "Flock" Article (it really DOES work magically well..:-) and glad I checked out your blog - lots of interesting, and enjoyable posts!

    :-)

    Ian
  • You're welcome, Ian. Thanks for dropping by and checking out my blog. :-)

    Ryan
  • I had two experiences in the last week to remind me that you're right about this, Ryan. First, I organized a new Meet Up for working moms who want to be home full time and need to replace their income with a home based business. Out of 7 women who came, most weren't sure what a blog was or anything about social media.

    Then we had our Bible study group for dinner last night and I was telling them how the Meet Up went and my blog in the works on the same topic. I mistakenly used a couple words like 'monetize' and 'platform' and even discussion 'threads.' Blank stares all around.

    We who hang out in this world forget how foreign it is to most of the population still. Out of charity I don't necessarily want to call it stupidity all around. For some it's just time and experience.

    But yeah, there's also a shocking lack of what used to pass as common sense out there.

    Becki
  • "Out of charity I don't necessarily want to call it stupidity all around. For some it's just time and experience."

    Becki - That's a great point. For some, they're not lacking in intelligence; they just haven't become active online yet.

    I do know a few of these bright-but-technophobic folks. A good friend of mine resisted the Internet for a long time, preferring paper to bytes. Now he's getting into programming. Go figure.

    Ryan
  • I overheard a phone conversation in my office the other that where someone had to explain that when entering a URL, you don't actually type the words "forward slash" you hit the forward slash key. You can never keep things too simple.
  • So true, Bryan. I was at Barnes & Noble last Friday and, apparently, the same thing happens in cake decorating. See CakeWrecks.com for major communication blunders that have shown up on cakes.
  • Ryan,

    I love the way how you run the theme from the sidewiki controversy over to the keep it simple principle and end up delivering advice on how to increase sales.
    Brilliant.

    I want to add two things.

    1. It checked out the #itshouldbeillegal theme on Twitter. I believe it was on Saturday. My jaw dropped. Even considering that people use shortcuts for words and expressions on twitter, ... leaving alone orthography, ... the thoughts and opinions could be frightening enough by themselves.

    2. One of the early, famous examples in usability engineering. In the late 80s some woman unpacked her new PC, plugged everything together; put the mouse on the floor. After awhile she called IBM support and complained, "Te pedal doesn't work quite well." Backstory: She was a seamstress. Her mental model of a user interface was originally formed by using a sewing machine. The mouse reminded her of the pedal.

    In usability engineering we say, "There is no dumb user, only bad user interfaces." However, ... looking at Twitter, I am not so sure about it anymore.

    Yours
    John

    P.S.: I learn new facts every day about wrong assumptions about "the Web, how it, and how its tools work." Even smart people get it often awfully wrong.

    P.P.S.: Back to sidewiki: Looking at history and society it seems that "stupid" and "evil" are usually the loudest.

    P.P.S.: This is for Michel Fortin. Ryan you probably know why :) Seems like I was in the flow.
  • Thank you, John! That's really fascinating how a seamstress thought her mouse should be used as a pedal. Our frame of reference strongly colors how we interpret new things.

    Ryan
  • Ryan, I've seen the same thing on twitter with trending topics - I'm sure some people just tweet a whole heap of whatever phrases they see in that box so they'll get some traffic. No idea if it works for them - I certainly wouldn't subscribe to follow that rubbish.

    I love John's seamstress example with the mouse - and I've got another one for you. A good friend of mine bought her mother a computer, set it up for her, had it all running properly, but kept getting calls that the mouse would only work side to side, it wouldn't work up and down. After several attempts to fix it over the phone, she went over to check out the problem.

    The mouse worked fine horizontally, but when it was raised from the desk (up) and lowered to it again (down) it did nothing.

    So yes, I agree with you Ryan, it's not always stupidity. It's often just unfamiliarity. Even the smartest among us have things we're "dumb" at - it's too specialised a world for it to be possible to be familiar with everything.
  • You said: "I'm sure some people just tweet a whole heap of whatever phrases they see in that box so they'll get some traffic."

    I've seen the same exact thing where a person pumps out 20 or 40 tweets all using the same trending topic hash tag. One or two tweets, okay. But dozens of them would have me hitting the unfollow button fast. :-)

    Ryan
  • Colin
    Ryan,

    I absolutely agree with everything you've written here... but I'm a little concerned by your diet. You only have breakfast once a week on Wednesday?

    ;)
  • Reeveso
    Hey Ryan - great post and you're absolutely right. People definitely will NOT understand sidewiki or know the difference between that and the website.

    Colin - I think he meant he goes out to eat for breakfast every Wednesday :)

    Jeremy Reeves
    www.ControlBeatingCopy.com
  • Colin
    Yes, I know... my winky emoticon wasn't sarcastic enough, I guess.
  • jodejong
    You didn't go far enough, Ryan! Twitter and its 140 characters is nothing compared to their other hangout--Ezine Articles with several hundred words to mutilate.
  • Hahaha! Too funny. Yes, I've run across a handful of poor writers there. ;-)

    Ryan
  • Hi Ryan,
    as my webdeveloper let me down with creating a website for me I could work with(yes, I am too stupid to use a CMS that requires to know a lot html) I decided on starting with WP. And as easy as it seems- I spend hours to understand and redo. So yes, I often wish things would be more plain and easy to understand. As a non English speaker I also find it dificult when english words are used and I have to find out what they mean...this is not a problem for you folks.
    And then I find lots of marketers who find it posh to use language noone understands and I ask myself: Do they really want to sell?
    One thing I often find is that many thoink that in BtoB language who "nornmal"people speak is not good enough for such highly educated people- what a lot of rubbish. By now I think they often don't understand it themselves...
    Ryan, your posts are esy to read - and still have lots to chew on.
    Thanks
  • Thank you, Heidi. And you bring up a great point: there are many non-English speaking buyers and plain language is much easier for them to understand.

    Ryan
  • I've posted this on our blog, but it's relevant here.

    Google is revealing how people are ignorant.

    Less than 8% of people surveyed by Google themselves knew what a "browser" is.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o4MwTvtyrUQ

    And now they expect people to know the difference between a website and Sidewiki???
  • I can't believe most people think Google and Yahoo are browsers... probably explains (to a degree) why Google dominates search.

    "Google is my browser!"

    You know what's even harder to explain? FTP.

    Trying to explain that over the phone is damn near impossible.

    Ryan
  • As someone who has worked tech support for 10 years, I'm not surprised. I was constantly having to explain what a browser was. I finally gave up and just started telling people to open Internet Explorer instead. Most of them got that.
  • Stacy - I think it's got to be partially an American thing.

    We're always shortening words, using slang... sacrificing specificity for generality. The same thing happens when we call a tissue a "Kleenex" or a browser "Internet Explorer."

    It's mental laziness. Americans are good at that. :-)

    Ryan
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: