Who Is Your True Competitor?

by Ryan M. Healy

in Business, Copywriting, Lessons

Do you know who your true competitor is?

Do you really know?

Nearly everybody has read about or heard of the success of Southwest airlines. While reading The Contrarian Effect by Michael Port and Elizabeth Marshall, I came across this little gem:

By offering low-cost fares, frequent flights, and fast, friendly service, Southwest quickly became a customer favorite — and a threat to the competition. Instead of focusing on its airline competitors, the company understood that the automobile was its true competitor and that it had to provide enough value for business travelers to decide to fly instead of drive. (p. 148, emphasis mine)

Most people assume their true competitors are those who are offering the same kind of product or service as they are.

But consider this:

  • A copywriter’s true competitor may not be a similarly talented copywriter, but may actually be the client himself! (Many times, a client is comparing the cost of hiring a copywriter to the cost/hassle of buying a how-to course and writing the copy himself.)
  • A company that sells skis may not really be competing with other ski manufacturers, but rather with those companies that manufacture, market, and sell snowboards.
  • A restaurant is not necessarily competing with other restaurants, but rather with the convenience and affordability of eating at home. (To increase business, perhaps restaurants need to tell the story of why eating out is a better option than eating at home.)

Whatever business you’re in, figure out who your true competitor really is. Once you figure this out, you may quickly find new ways to strengthen your offers and draw in more clients and customers.

-Ryan M. Healy

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
  • Who Is Your True Competitor? http://twurl.nl/i0×1wj Thanks @healymonster


    This comment was originally posted on Twitter

  • Hey Ryan, as usual, you cause me to think and that is always a good thing. Never considered the South West thing before, but having that think out side the box mentality is crucial in this day and age.
    I think that before you can figure out who your true competitors are, you’d better first realize that knowing what separates you from the pack is the first and most important thing you can do. Why, because it doesn’t matter if you try and sale them on why they should buy from you rather then from x competitor, if you don’t have that unique factor about you, you’ll be just another voice screaming in the crowd I hope that what I am saying makes since, thanks for the post keep them coming
  • As a consumer, we always weigh costs.

    For instance, we were looking for the best deal to get to Cancun. In January we found plenty flights (flew in late April and just got back a week ago, the beginning of May) for $385. Unfortunately, they went through Houston, Atlanta, or Miami.

    We chose a $515 flight direct from LAX and back. It only takes 4 hours to get there and 5 hours back (who knew?) and there is no worries of missing your luggage and having to run the length of terminal B in Denver like we did last year so we wouldn't miss a connecting flight.

    In this case, the real competition was inconvenience.

    Looking beyond the obvious has become mandatory for marketers and copywriters like us to stay ahead of the competition, no matter who the competition is.

    As is normal Ryan, you provoke thought and add value to the world around you. Thanks for that.
  • I should steal your brain.

    Seriously, you're too good to be left on the world wide web. You might steal my clients :D
  • Yup. I've been advocating this position since at least 1991, when I wrote about an ad from a group of florists telling people not to buy their flowers in a grocery store.

    I started my business as a typing service; my competitor became PCs. By then I was writing resumes, but the MS Word template pretty much killed that. Fortunately, I'd already moved into copywriting :-).
  • Who’s your real competition? A great post from copywriter Ryan Healy. http://twurl.nl/qohchr


    This comment was originally posted on Twitter

  • Jeremy Reeves
    Wow - how true! I've heard that about Southwest airlines before but this time it really "stuck".

    Great post Ryan!

    Jeremy Reeves
    www.ControlBeatingCopy.com
  • @Marya - Yes, it always helps to see things from a new perspective.

    @Joe - On a personal level, I agree. Our greatest competition is ourselves. (That's why I always preferred individual sports.)

    @D.K. - Thanks for the insightful comment!
  • Their real competition was the automobile. Insightful.

    Here's how to identify your true competition:

    1. Consider the end result that your customer is looking for, NOT necessarily the mechanism, the means, or the vehicle.

    In the case Southwest, the end result the customer was looking for to get to their destination, and NOT necesarily use the mechanism of flying. As Southwest realized, the plane was only a means to an end.

    (Think laterally, not vertically.)

    2. Identify all the ways, or means, through which your customer can get to their destination. Again, as exemplified by the Southwest example, they identified that the automobile was another way for their customers to attain the same ultimate result of using their airline service.

    It would be too narrow to just identify other airlines as the competition--or, in this case, not only as the competition, but also as the means--for the customer to get what they want.

    3. Then, resolve to make your service better in some way. Not just better than the other servcies in it's category (that would be like Southwest only trying to be better than other airlines), but better than all other options, whether they be walking, driving, busing--you get what I mean.
  • Joe
    I believe your true competitor is yourself, always. What you're talking about makes total sense, but what that really is, is trends in your market place .

    It's a jungle out there, no matter how you slice it.

    Great blog Ryan.

    Joe
  • Wow, Ryan - I don't think I've ever heard anyone put it better.

    It makes a great case for always pushing oneself to think beyond the obvious solution and see how much further one can take a subject.
  • Who Is Your True Competitor?: Do you know who your true competitor is?

    Do you really know?


    Nearly everybody has .. http://tinyurl.com/cjhc8b


    This comment was originally posted on Twitter

blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: